Home
Feature Article
Top 5 MLB Games of the Last Decade

As the 2010 baseball season gets underway, it's kind of hard to believe that it is already 2010. Looking back, the years 2000-2010 were truly a golden era for baseball gaming. Out of all the sports that were digitally re-created this past decade, baseball games faced the most competition, which led to many outstanding titles that were created by multiple development studios.

In celebration of baseball's opening week -- and in an effort to compile the top five baseball games of the decade -- I have spent the last three weekends huddled in my basement feverishly playing some of the best baseball titles from the past 10 years.

With so many worthy candidates, narrowing the list down to just five was no easy task. It should be noted that each game chosen not only had to demonstrate superior gameplay, but also had to leave a distinct impression on the genre as a whole.

Three weeks of intense baseball gaming, a broken Dreamcast controller, several pots of coffee, and one angry wife later, I give you Christian McLeod's Top 5 Baseball Games of the Last Decade.

5. MLB 2001 (2000, PS1)

Simply put, MLB '01 was the best baseball game to ever grace the Playstation 1. With beautiful player models and detailed stadiums, MLB 2001 pushed the limits of what was visually possible in a baseball game near the end of the PS1's lifespan.

What really set the game apart from others in the genre, however, was that it was the first game to ever include a bare bones manager mode and an extremely impressive spring training mode. In the spring training mode, you could create a player and then work through the spring to earn points that could be used to improve his stats before the start of the MLB season. Sound familiar? That's right, MLB '01 included the basic framework for Road to the Show mode, and it was completely revolutionary at the time.

4. All-Star Baseball 2003 (2002, PC)

Hardcore baseball fanatics will undoubtedly agree that the All-Star Baseball series was one of the most overlooked in all of baseball gaming history. After a somewhat rocky start on the N64, the All-Star franchise peaked with the release of the outstanding 2003 edition. With a 20 year franchise mode, some of the deepest stat tracking to date and some of the most authentic baseball atmosphere (pitchers wore coats when they reached base!) to ever grace the PS2/Xbox, All-Star Baseball 2003 was the closest thing to a true representation of the sport of baseball I had ever seen at the time. If you have never played this game, you can not call yourself a baseball fan.

It is a shame that the developers never received the commercial praise they deserved for this series. All-Star Baseball 2003 will forever go down as one of the best pure simulations of the sport.

 


World Series Baseball 2K3

3. World Series Baseball 2K3 (2003, PS2/Xbox)

2002 was a great year for baseball gaming. In addition to All-Star Baseball 2003, there was another top-tier title released called World Series Baseball 2K3. World Series 2K3 featured amazing graphics, ESPN presentation, signature player styles and some of the best fielding camera angles I have ever seen in a baseball game.

The exceptional player control and batting physics in the game made multiplayer games a blast, and spending hours upon hours in dynasty mode never got old due to the variety of player animations -- no game ever felt the same. Additionally, this is one of those games that looks so good, especially with the ESPN overlays, that it still gets a ton of playtime when my PS2 is booted up.

2. MLB 08: The Show (2007, PS3)

Let me just put it this way: I bought a PS3 just for MLB 08. Never in my life had I seen a baseball game look as realistic as this title, and the polished gameplay made my inner baseball geek rejoice. The game's RttS mode was pure addictive fun, and I literally spent days of my life entrenched in the game's deep dynasty mode.

What really set the game apart from any other baseball game was just how well it captured the "soul" of baseball. All the little nuances of the game had been digitally re-created, from the emotion of a walk-off home run to the despair of blowing a save to the excitement of a home crowd as their team mounts a two-out rally. Very seldom does a game come along that completely defines what is possible in a genre on a certain generation of consoles, but MLB 08 was that game.

1. MVP Baseball 05 (2004, PC/Xbox/PS2)

What more can really be said about a game that was so successful that its core mechanics are still being mimicked to this very day? They say imitation is the most sincere form of flattery, which must mean that EA’s now-defunct MVP development team is beyond flattered that the game mechanics from MVP 2005 are still being used today. Meter-based pitching and fielding, analog slides, picture-in-picture batting feedback, the "hitter's eye" and analog stick hit influence have all become genre standards during the past couple of years.

The greatest aspect of MVP Baseball was something that no other console baseball game has been able to implement to date: an owner mode. MVP allowed any aspiring George Steinbrenners the opportunity to put together a team, build a stadium and keep a rabid fan base happy -- all while being fiscally responsible. Knowing that this game mode could actually end if my finances spent too much time in the red conveyed a sense of ownership of my team that I have yet to experience in another game.

MVP Baseball will forever go down in history as one of the greatest baseball games to ever be released -- as evidenced by the legions of fans still playing the game with 2010 mods on PC -- and it is my pick for baseball game of the decade.


So what were your favorite baseball games during the last 10 years? Sound off below.


Member Comments
# 41 Juiceman @ 04/15/10 01:33 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by aukevin
Last time I bought OOTP (3 years ago maybe) it came with generic rosters, is it different now? There were MLB rosters that you downloaded and added to it, but the base game was generic. Maybe I'm thinking of a different game (Puresim or something like that).
Real rosters come with the game.
 
# 42 Altimus @ 04/15/10 02:09 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pared
You know, I typically feel Christian's content is so off-the-mark when it comes to the sports genre, but this isn't that bad as a list. The exclusion of HH though is just... head-scratcher, close to being number 5 or not.

HH pushed sim-style gaming harder than most other baseball titles did out of the box.


Strongly disagree. The game had a sim slider for a reason. They left it up to the user to decide.

While some tweaks were nice, I could change minor things to my liking because I wanted less reliance on my input and more reliance on ratings... which were typically very well done. Players performed like you expected.


You don't know what you're talking about. WSB 2k3 was right up there with realism compared to HH.

Sure, it had an issue where all the catcher's arms were over powered making steals difficult. But you always had realistic results, and players performed how you would expect right out of the box.
I loved that game. Couldn't wait to get out of school just to play it. ESPN presentation made it that much better as well.
 
# 43 BrownsFan72 @ 04/15/10 09:36 PM
How can the High heat series not be in the top 5!
 
# 44 Bumble14 @ 04/16/10 11:43 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pared
You know, I typically feel Christian's content is so off-the-mark when it comes to the sports genre, but this isn't that bad as a list. The exclusion of HH though is just... head-scratcher, close to being number 5 or not.

HH pushed sim-style gaming harder than most other baseball titles did out of the box.


Strongly disagree. The game had a sim slider for a reason. They left it up to the user to decide.

While some tweaks were nice, I could change minor things to my liking because I wanted less reliance on my input and more reliance on ratings... which were typically very well done. Players performed like you expected.


You don't know what you're talking about. WSB 2k3 was right up there with realism compared to HH.

Sure, it had an issue where all the catcher's arms were over powered making steals difficult. But you always had realistic results, and players performed how you would expect right out of the box.
Pared-

As I said before, HH was up there on this list, and would come in at #6. As much as I loved the series I could not justify it over my other 5 choices.

Sorry you feel that I am "so off the mark" when it comes to the genre- I call it like I see it and don't sugar coat a lot. Feel free to PM me as I;d welcome your feedback.

Chrstian
 
# 45 Pared @ 04/16/10 02:30 PM
PM'd.

Quote:
Originally Posted by BrownsFan72
How can the High heat series not be in the top 5!
That seems to be the general consensus and I think it's very justifiable to see at least ONE of HH's titles there. (IMO, probably HH2003 or 2004)
 
# 46 bcruise @ 04/16/10 02:52 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pared
Strongly disagree. The game had a sim slider for a reason. They left it up to the user to decide.
Good point, but I think the sim slider had more to do with outcomes than what the game actually looked like (which is the point I was making with the floaty curveballs). What I mean is, with that slider to full you could swing late on a fastball with Barry Bonds and pull it 450 feet, just because he's Barry Bonds. On full sim slider it just kind of felt like the game played itself sometimes, with user input having a very small effect on outcomes.

The tune file allowed us to change things that actually changed the way the game looked (throw speeds in MPH for example!!), not just the results the game put out.

I loved HH too of course and am also surprised it didn't make this list.
 
# 47 Pared @ 04/16/10 03:05 PM
I agree with you there. You're more focused on the look... but this was HH we're talking about. C'mon!

I think most kind of turned a blind eye to the graphics. Mike Piazza did what you expected him to do, ya know?

Most games at the time didn't have such a strong grasp on their ratings=outcomes. And it felt like HH had just the right balance between ratings and user input.

The Show has emulated it well and that's part of why I see it being so popular.
 
# 48 Bat @ 04/16/10 08:41 PM
Mvp 05 is the most overrated baseball game ever! *WITH MODS* on the PC, it is solid. Other than that, nothing special.

High Heat definitely should be in this list. Also Ncaa Baseball (the first one) was awesome. Pitching with Lincecum on the UW Huskies was a blast. Best hitting mechanics as well.

Basically give me The Shows graphics, and gameplay, Allstars franchise mode, 2k rock and fire pitching with Ncaa hitting , and the editability of High Heat and it would be the holy grail of baseball games.
 
# 49 duke776 @ 04/16/10 09:14 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bkrich83
ASB, had a fabulous franchise mode, plus expansion mode, which no one has ever been able to match, But was lackluster on the field. It really didn't "play" a very good game of baseball.
I was really dissapointed that game had no sliders so we couldn't tweak it to play better. I absolutely loved the franchise and expansion mode on that game, but the on the field play turned me off.
 
# 50 bkrich83 @ 04/17/10 01:43 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bat9th
Mvp 05 is the most overrated baseball game ever! *WITH MODS* on the PC, it is solid. Other than that, nothing special.

High Heat definitely should be in this list. Also Ncaa Baseball (the first one) was awesome. Pitching with Lincecum on the UW Huskies was a blast. Best hitting mechanics as well.

Basically give me The Shows graphics, and gameplay, Allstars franchise mode, 2k rock and fire pitching with Ncaa hitting , and the editability of High Heat and it would be the holy grail of baseball games.
Agreed on all counts.
 
# 51 AndyP @ 04/18/10 02:00 PM
I consider the MLB The Show series to more or less dominate all 5 positions in the "Top 5 of the decade". That said, I'd give an honorable mention to all of the games mentioned - ASB, which before The Show was the game that incorporated many of the nuances of baseball more than any other; MVP and High Heat. Of course, I think 2k have finally stepped up their game with 2k10 this year. I never really understood the obsession with MVP05 as a great game - good, but not great.
 
# 52 bh446066 @ 04/28/10 04:28 PM
For me (and I haven't played all the titles, mind you, the list would be:

1. MLB 08 The Show
2. High Heat 2004
3. MLB 10 The Show (might end up being #1 by the time it's said and done)
4. MVP Baseball 2004
 
# 53 TheMatrix31 @ 04/28/10 08:59 PM
MLB Power Pros 2008 belongs in the discussion.
 
# 54 hitstreak13 @ 05/02/10 02:45 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by JJLinn
MVP is the best sports game of all time IMO. Lord knows how many hours I spent playing it.
I'm still playing it lol. If this game had 40-man rosters, waivers, Rule 5, etc. I truly believe this game will still be in most peoples game systems. The owner mode is just fantastic.
 
# 55 Blzer @ 05/04/10 06:07 PM
Not mentioning Interplay Sports Baseball 2000 for PSX is a fail on every level.

EDIT: Oh duh, and MLB Power Pros (haven't played 2008).
 
# 56 ExtremeGamer @ 05/05/10 06:14 AM
1. MVP 2005
2. ASB 2003
3. High Heat 2002
4. MLB Power Pros 08
5. High Heat 2004
 
# 57 Blzer @ 05/11/10 11:43 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by bulls23
4. World Series Baseball 95 on Sega Genesis
Definitely is not of the last decade.
 
# 58 ZFarls @ 06/21/10 01:32 PM
Great list, Although, I would squeeze N64 ASB 2k1 (red cartridge D. Jeter) on the list probably in the 3 slot.

I played MVP religiously and is a top 5 all time game for me, great soundtrack too.
 
# 59 hitstreak13 @ 06/21/10 05:20 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by daflyboys
People forget how good ASB was and should be considered for this list. The limitation of updating rosters is what kills it though (unless someone has cracked that?).
I would love to hear that someone has. I wrote in another thread that ASB 05 has the best rule 5, roster management by the cpu, etc. The CPU did one hell of a job protecting top prospects. If I can update the rosters, I will def. play this game once again.
 
# 60 hitstreak13 @ 06/21/10 07:19 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by daflyboys
Now it makes me wonder that if it can be copied to the HD of a "special" xbox, if there is a roster file that could potentially be overwritten.
That is pretty interesting idea (if it works). I just wish this game had sliders. Anyways, PM if something interesting develops or let me know if I can do anything to help.
 


Post A Comment
Only OS members can post comments
Please login or register to post a comment.