Home
Feature Article
What Features Should Sports Games Borrow From One Another?

With the year's cycle of sports games starting to come in full effect, it's apparent that we'll likely go one more year without the "perfect" sports title. That is perfectly OK, of course. There hasn't been a perfect game up to this point and it's reasonable to assume there won't be one for a while. Collectively, however, there's enough to draw from each individual title to make something great. For instance, what if Madden had a coaching carousel mode similar to College Hoops 2K8 and NCAA Football 2014? Or maybe if Rory Mcllroy PGA Tour had The Golf Club's intricate course design? These are all things that are easy to fantasize about, but just as easy to shove aside as things that will never happen. But why can't they? There is no reason why games should be so afraid to borrow from another series. With that said, here are a few features that games would be shrewd to obtain.

NCAA Basketball's Dual Presentation

There are a lot of reasons why this hasn't happened yet. Getting a dual presentation with two separate broadcasts provides a unique challenge, in that you not only have to fork up the money for the rights of several different voices (and in NCAA's case, two separate brands in CBS and ESPN), but that you're also doing twice the work. And for games that come out on an annual basis, this might have to be a project that spans past a release or two. So with that being said, is it still worth it? Absolutely.

Even though NCAA Basketball 10 hadn't tapped into the feature's true potential, having the unique option of choosing between two different broadcasts brought a sense of originality to each game. ESPN could broadcast your in-season games and CBS - such as they do in real life - the postseason games. This kind of feature could easily work with other games, as most sports broadcast from separate channels. Not to mention, the voices of Phil Simms and Eric Karros have grown tiresome to many. Simply giving an alternative may be the best option.

Games that could use the feature: Madden, MLB: The Show, PGA Tour, NBA Live

NBA 2K's MyLeague

MyLeague hasn't been a total success, so far. Still, it represents a part of sports gaming that desperately needs more attention: customization inside of franchise modes.

Things like trade frequency, player progression, and salary negotiations should always have sliders so that the user can tweak them to their liking. I trust that as NBA 2K fine tunes this mode, more games will pick it up and utilize it.

Games that could use the feature: MLB: The Show, Madden, FIFA

MLB: The Show's dedication to core gameplay

This isn't exactly a feature, but it's something that nearly every sports title could use. The other two games (FIFA/NBA 2K) which have also found a strong core to build off of are also in the midst of a successful run. It is arguably the most important aspect of any sports game, and even though The Show often catches flak for its lack of change, it's ability to consistently move forward without ever taking a step back should be admired. In fact, this strong core is exactly what puts a game like MLB: The Show in tremendous shape to take a risk when it feels that it's time to do so, given how much trust it has won over from its consumers.

Games that could use this feature: Madden, NBA Live, WWE 2K


Member Comments
# 1 SHAKYR @ 05/13/15 04:19 PM
Depth! Presentation, Creation modes, Tendencies, realism, atomsphere. MLB: The Show and 2K; some of 2K's features because they took a backstep on some features.
 
# 2 bxphenom7 @ 05/13/15 04:26 PM
I used to like Madden's team relocation feature, and MVP's stadium builder. I wish all sports games included these. Stadium creation would add to "ultimate team"-like modes and owner/franchise modes.

In terms of presentation, it shouldn't take a license to have good presentation. They just have to do to what they would do with a license without the network license. Not difficult.
 
# 3 huntt26 @ 05/13/15 05:06 PM
Every sports game needs TeamBuilder-type features. Build a team, build a stadium, build a uniform, etc all on a website. Then enjoy in game.
 
# 4 Ghost Of The Year @ 05/13/15 05:14 PM
I really wish Madden & NBA2K would take a page from the Show as far as creating historical rosters go.
I wish the Show would go as deep into customisation as OOTP does.
 
# 5 malky @ 05/13/15 06:26 PM
The Show's FRANCHISE SAVE ---

And of course NFL2K5--- stilll waiting for someone to copy a ten year old presentation that should be in all games.
 
# 6 Vermin @ 05/13/15 06:36 PM
The Dual-presentation aspect is definitely interesting. I would love to see (though cost and logistics make this unlikely) at least team-specific broadcast graphics, even if the commentary remained the same. Why stop at CBS and ESPN? How about WGN for Cubs home games? Fox Sports for Tigers, Royals, etc? Or Sportsnet coverage of the Blue Jays?
 
# 7 MUCHLUV69 @ 05/13/15 06:59 PM
MADDEN16 can we PLEASE have a out of town ticker showing up live scores around the league. After playing my franchise game it is so ridiculous to press advance week button. Madden16 needs to emerge me in my season...do actual football fans make Madden?!?!?!
 
# 8 Xoax34 @ 05/13/15 07:14 PM
I dont even mind that much about licensed presentation as long as they can create a realistic looking one along with you know...
Free throw line stat overlays, postgame interview stat overlays, etc.

NBA 2K i swear to god get rid of the cheesy stupid twitter crap. NBA.com was much better.
 
# 9 TMalone2010 @ 05/14/15 12:27 AM
Connected careers would be cool in MLB and 2K

Year to year saves should be in every game
 
# 10 KennyJ1976 @ 05/14/15 02:54 AM
All sports games should have more than one commentary team, something done in NCAA Basketball 6 years ago and done in FIFA 15 now. Also I think all sports game should have a story mode, something similar to Fight Night Champion. All crowds in sports games should look like the crowds in MLB The Show 15 and all sports games should have weekly studio shows like College Hoops 2K8 or NFL 2K5, but instead of putting a digital version of the guys in the game, do what NHL 15 did and use the real guys with a green screen behind them. One more thing about commentary, there should be a guy that does score updates from other games around the league like they do in FIFA 15. I can come up with more, but I'll end with this. Madden needs to have real players and coaches on the sideline like pretty much every other sports game on the market.
 
# 11 menloe24 @ 05/14/15 03:10 PM
My "Pet Peeve" is why doesn't Madden have a "score ticker" of other league games that are going on in offline franchise leagues?? Like NCAA Football '14 had the ESPN "Bottom Line".

Highlights from other games (ex: Game winning plays, major injuries, etc) would make the game so much more of an immersive feeling.

NCAA Basketball on CBS was the greatest sports broadcast presentation/graphics of any sports game ever. NHL 15 did a good job this year as well.

EA Sports seems too many resources on "who is going to be on the cover", than making the game presentation better.
 
# 12 OrangeFriendlyFrog @ 05/16/15 06:33 PM
Year-to-Year saves. It's ridiculous that MLB The Show is the only one doing this.
 
# 13 Gotmadskillzson @ 05/19/15 08:19 PM
1. Every sports game should have a PC version. It saddens me that only NBA 2K and FIFA have a PC version. But yet every sports game have a tablet/Phone version.

2. Every sports game should have NBA 2K end of the game highlight reel system where every individual player game highlights are stored.

3. Every sports game should have MLB The Show presentation elements mixed in with NBA Live halftime and post game shows. I also like NBA Live's camera angles.

4. Every sports game should have MLB The Show animation system and AI. Out of all the sports games, The Shows AI seem to be the best. I never did like the way players move in EA Sports games and the AI in EA Sports games are brain dead far too often.

5. Every sports game should have MLB The Show style slider system mixed with NBA 2K's rating and tendency system. The more ratings, tendencies and sliders the better. That is of course they all work as intended......yeah I'm looking at you EA...

6. Every sports game should have coach mode.
 
# 14 darryl.oliver @ 05/20/15 02:27 PM
I really think the most important thing is presentation. I don't buy a baseball game to feel like I'm paying baseball. I play it to feel like I am about to hit a game winning hit at Wrigley. Why this seems to allude some makers confuses me.
 

Post A Comment
Only OS members can post comments
Please login or register to post a comment.