Madden NFL 10: Top Ten Position Ratings (Gamespot)

[c dizzy m baby]

Donny, the 2 Raiders on that list you rated very fairly, but how is Zach Miller not in the Top 10 TE's? John Carlson and Shockey are better? Ill give it to Shockey based on his past and potential, but Carlson? Miller is a FANTASTIC blocker, has excellent hands, runs great routes, and is the most consistent offensive player on the Raiders team, not to mention they run the SAME speed. He had more catches and yards on a worse offense, *with worse tackles*. Once the Raiders upgrade their OT (which isn't hard to upgrade the worst starting OTs in the NFL in recent memory) allowing Miller to free up I guarantee you he will be a Pro Bowl TE. The skill is already there, he is just waiting on the opportunity.

[jbooc13]

I woulnt say to 10,but right behind shockey at 82-84

[83evans]

Moorman- 97
Stroud- 92
Whitner- 87
Evans- 87
Owens- 86
Lynch- 85
Butler- 84
Walker- 84
Schobel- 83
Pos- 81
Mitchell- 80
McKelvin- 79
McGee- 78
Edwards- 77
Reed- 77
Jackson- 79

[kcarr]

Quote: Originally Posted by jbooc13

Tomlinson was still 10th in rushing last year...which was his worst year EVER.He deserves to be in top 5 for now

Just had his worst year ever, is old and probably won't bounce back but rather will continue to decline, averaged like 3.8 YPC. Top 10 in yards does not by itself make you a top 5 back.

[dave374]

Ranking Romo ahead of Eli Manning is a joke.
Manning has won a Super Bowl and proven himself.
All Romo has done is forced Jessica Simpson to get fat and lost every playoff game he's played in.
I'm more bitter about the Simpson thing, but you know where I'm going with this.

[kmart2180]

Donny, I think Rivers is a bit to low.

Should look like this IMO

1 Manning
2 Brady
3 Brees
4 Warner
5 Big Ben
6 Rivers
7a McNaab
7b Cutler
9 Pennington
10 Manning
11 Romo

[achain]

According to this, Fred Smoot is a better corner than D. Hall.

Why doesn't that sound right.

[da ThRONe]

So many issues with these ratings! *SMH*

Who thinks Roddy White is better than Calvin Johnson thats a joke.

Donovan McNabb is a top 5 QB. Who besides Brady has done more with less and is ask to do it passing as much as Andy Reid passes the ball?

Larry Johnson is still an elite running back no love. Everybody gets all wrapped up in hype way to fast. Cassell is a 83 please remember Derek Anderson after that year he was rated all high now he probably back in the 60's.

These rating are based on hype not actual talent and the still are way to high. Just these ratings alone proves this scaling down thing is a joke. Its the same as 09 just with this year inflated players!