NCAA Football 10 Demo Now Available, Post Your Impressions Here

[JAYMO76]

Quote: Originally Posted by stingmgt

Am I the only one that thinks the throwing is completely ********? You can be running backwards in the pocket and throw an absolute strike across the field. The quarterbacks don't even step into their throws. You hit the button to pass it and dude throws a rope anywhere in the area code. It looks so ridiculous that it's actually funny. Funny, did you hear that. It's turned into a funny arcade game. This demo is unplayable. Are you kidding me with the passing?

I wouldn't be so harsh regarding the demo, but I will say that completion percentage is still too high (for completions and int's).

[Heisman316]

Quote: Originally Posted by stingmgt

Am I the only one that thinks the throwing is completely ********? You can be running backwards in the pocket and throw an absolute strike across the field. The quarterbacks don't even step into their throws. You hit the button to pass it and dude throws a rope anywhere in the area code. It looks so ridiculous that it's actually funny. Funny, did you hear that. It's turned into a funny arcade game. This demo is unplayable. Are you kidding me with the passing?

The demo is unplayable, yet you're playig it aren't you?

The NCAA series is better this year. The animations are way better. The changes this year are really getting overlooked by people this year.

The NCAA series or any football game can't improve too much more. I mean what else do you want other than to run, pass, and play defense?

[mjussawalla]

Quote: Originally Posted by Heisman316

The demo is unplayable, yet you're playig it aren't you? The NCAA series is better this year. The animations are way better. The changes this year are really getting overlooked by people this year. The NCAA series or any football game can't improve too much more. I mean what else do you want other than to run, pass, and play defense?

I agree with you that so far, this is the best NCAA on next gen.

But I think there is a lot more they can do gameplay and presentation wise.

[el bandolero]

Quote: Originally Posted by Heisman316

The demo is unplayable, yet you're playig it aren't you? The NCAA series is better this year. The animations are way better. The changes this year are really getting overlooked by people this year. The NCAA series or any football game can't improve too much more. I mean what else do you want other than to run, pass, and play defense?

Are you serious? By those standards, NFL Blitz is on the same level as a Flight Simulation. Here's top 3 things EA would need to add to make this game playable, 1.) Some regard for the laws of physics, 2.) actual run blocking, and a real pocket, not the "Make our straight line blocking, then inexeplicably just turn sideways" they have the tackles doing. 3.) Real crowd noise or presentation, just port the last gen sounds. Those new animations are not impressive, they're just a bunch of ragdoll tackles, there is no way in the world that when im running straight down the field full speed that you will grab my shoulder and spin me to the ground.

[Heisman316]

Quote: Originally Posted by el bandolero

Are you serious? By those standards, NFL Blitz is on the same level as a Flight Simulation. Here's top 3 things EA would need to add to make this game playable, 1.) Some regard for the laws of physics, 2.) actual run blocking, and a real pocket, not the "Make our straight line blocking, then inexeplicably just turn sideways" they have the tackles doing. 3.) Real crowd noise or presentation, just port the last gen sounds. Those new animations are not impressive, they're just a bunch of ragdoll tackles, there is no way in the world that when im running straight down the field full speed that you will grab my shoulder and spin me to the ground.

It's ridicoulous(sp?) how many people expect this series to be better than what it is, is what I'm saying.

Granted, the presentation could be better, but the gameplay is football. The tackles are better, the deep ball works, the running game works, the plays work.

Everything football related works, was what I was trying to get across. People need to appreciate whats in the game, not complain about what isn't.

[rudyjuly2]

Quote: Originally Posted by Heisman316

It's ridicoulous(sp?) how many people expect this series to be better than what it is, is what I'm saying. Everything football related works, was what I was trying to get across. People need to appreciate whats in the game, not complain about what isn't.

It's fine to have that approach. But don't criticize others for expecting more from the game. Complaining about complaining is counter productive.

I'd like to have a nice camera angle for one and I liked the '09 one. Explain to me why I should be happy about the new camera they have which I dislike? Why did they get rid of the old one?

[el bandolero]

Quote: Originally Posted by Heisman316

It's ridicoulous(sp?) how many people expect this series to be better than what it is, is what I'm saying. Granted, the presentation could be better, but the gameplay is football. The tackles are better, the deep ball works, the running game works, the plays work. Everything football related works, was what I was trying to get across. People need to appreciate whats in the game, not complain about what isn't.

Well i agree with the expectations being too high for what is basically a secondary product for EA, I in no way agree that the football is correct in this game. The tackles are ridiculous, especially when the RB breaks 5 just because the game decides its their 'impact' moment, the running game by no means works, there is 0 second level blocking, the plays work? I guess, they do what's drawn for them. Everything football related does not work, and that's why i won't buy this game, offensive line/defensive line interaction is complete garbage, and makes this game unbearable for a lot of people.

[wickedbadman]

Quote: Originally Posted by el bandolero

Well i agree with the expectations being too high for what is basically a secondary product for EA, I in no way agree that the football is correct in this game. The tackles are ridiculous, especially when the RB breaks 5 just because the game decides its their 'impact' moment, the running game by no means works, there is 0 second level blocking, the plays work? I guess, they do what's drawn for them. Everything football related does not work, and that's why i won't buy this game, offensive line/defensive line interaction is complete garbage, and makes this game unbearable for a lot of people.

It's about as close to an accurate representation of football as when me and 6 guys go play in an empty parking lot.

Garbage might be going to easy on the O/D line interaction. The lack of explosion by the DE, and the magical suction they have to the O line when the QB leaves the pocket still boggles my mind.