Top Five MLB Games of the Last Decade

[dickey1331]

Quote: Originally Posted by Trustpt

I'd just change the top order: #1 MLB 10: The Show, #2 MVP Baseball 05

Agreed.

[Blublub]

I agree with everyone that High Heat in some form HAS to be on any top 5 list. I'd easily drop ASBB. While it did have some revolutionary features at the time (e.g. working scoreboards), it pretty much played like poo. And how many people played MLB 2001 on the PS1? Wasn't the platform dead by then?

Also, shouldn't this include text sims? If so, how could OOTP in some form be left off?

I think there were enough innovative and/or interesting titles during the past decade to warrant a top ten...

[jpup]

The Show 10, 09, 08, 07, 2006. That's the list.

[roadman]

HH is on my decade list, too bad it didn't make this list. I'm a stats person, and HH had the closest to ML stats as possible out of the other games besides The Show.

[boinker]

Agreed with all the choices.

[jaxpac]

HIgh heat being left out is a major flaw with this list.

[Garcia]

1. The Show '10
2. The Show '09
3. The Show '08
4. High Heat
5. MVP '05 - the most overrated "great" game in my opinion.

[bkrich83]

Gonna have to disagree with this list.

MVP 05 imo, most overhyped overrated baseball game of all time.

ASB, had a fabulous franchise mode, plus expansion mode, which no one has ever been able to match, But was lackluster on the field. It really didn't "play" a very good game of baseball.

MVP 05 is #1, ASB is on the list, but no mention of the HH games? I don't get it. The HH series set the bar for true baseball simulations. I simply can not see how they are left off, but a game like ASB or even MLB 01 is on the list.