Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

[ajf14]

Quote: Originally Posted by redsoxallday

Drew Brees 99?!!!? Peyton Manning 99?!!!? am i missing something?

yeah, the QB ratings are crazy. brees is good, but i see him more in the 97 range. manning is the best QB though, so it's fair

[Unforgiven]

Quote: Originally Posted by colombian9kid

Polite is better than weaver at FB? Jason peters isn't a top 5 LT? jamal Jackson isn't a top 5 C? And quintin Mikell isn't a top 5 SS????????!!!!!!!!!

Have you watched Polite play? He is EASILY the best blocking fullback in the league, and is a monster at converting for 1st down's in short yardage. Now, put them both at HB and Weaver is far better. As a true fullback though, Polite is much better.

[ElijahThePatsFan]

To people raging about speed ratings (especially Nick Collins) being low: Now, I haven't watched any of the players you're talking about, but it may be possible that with the new speed/acceleration system, they'll just have really high acceleration.

[lippe1888]

Quote: Originally Posted by ajf14

yeah, the QB ratings are crazy. brees is good, but i see him more in the 97 range. manning is the best QB though, so it's fair

Yea. Brees is really good but Peyton's an all-time great. Its only cuz hes on the cover and won the SB

[angels eclipse7]

Quote: Originally Posted by lippe1888

Yea. Brees is really good but Peyton's an all-time great. Its only cuz hes on the cover and won the SB

That is true, but the ratings should be about who is the best right now. Not who is the best over their career. If Joe Montana made a come back, they wouldn't rate him a 99. He isn't what he used to be and his rating should reflect it.

[Chargersa7x]

IMO FIFA does a much better job with ratings, and I remember right they have like three players in the 90s

[Exonerated]

Quote: Originally Posted by Chargersa7x

IMO FIFA does a much better job with ratings, and I remember right they have like three players in the 90s

Before the season, Ronaldo 93, Messi 91.

[pittsburgher86]

HOW IN THE WORLD IS BEN ROETHLISBERGER NOT ON THE BEST QB LIST? HE IS CLEARY BETTER THEN GUYS LIKE SHAUB AND PHILLIP RIVERS! Does production mean anything to the ratings. Ben has one 2 superbowls! HE EVEN WON THE GAME FOR THE STEELERS IN SUPER BOWL 43! Sure Ben is stupid, with his off the field problems, but I hope they didnt take anything like that in to account. Well, I know I will be editing his attributes. Also kind of surpised about Brady.