Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top Players at Each Position (K0ACHK)

[SaintsFan2544]

Quote: Originally Posted by CaliDude916

LMAO! Brady is not a 98. 95 is right where he should be.

So true

[tooldude79]

Quote: Originally Posted by Patriots1996

Brees at 99? Thats the biggest bunch of crap I've heard all year! I hate how the coverboy and his team are biased! Hes a 95 at best! Manning and Brady at 98 at best! No NFL QB is a 99 right now, and I'm a Colts fan.

funny post
last season, Brees won the super bowl(MVP), broke the all-time completion % record for a season, had a stellar td/int ratio, and the year before he threw for 5,000 yards(his leading receiver, lance moore, had less than 1,000 yards)

if he doesnt deserve a 99 rating, noone does

[Gosens6]

Yes Brees deserves a 99 rating, look at his stats for the past TWO years, not just last year. I'm saying this without even being a Saints fan. Some of the homers in this thread are hilarious.

[acarrero]

Absurd rating for Big Ben. He should be at least a 94. He is proven to be a better QB than Rogers and obviously Shaub. Rivers is better than Ben? LOL!!! Where's McNabb? He belongs in the 90's too.

[Gosens6]

Quote: Originally Posted by acarrero

Absurd rating for Big Ben. He should be at least a 94. He is proven to be a better QB than Rogers and obviously Shaub. Rivers is better than Ben? LOL!!! Where's McNabb? He belongs in the 90's too.

Ben Roethlisberger, QB PIT 506 337 66.6 4328 8.55 60 26 12 50 100.5 283

Aaron Rodgers, QB GNB 541 350 64.7 4434 8.20 83 30 7 50 103.2 277

Looks clear to me that Rodgers proved he's a better QB last year. SB wins mean nothing with Madden ratings.

[reyes the roof]

Quote: Originally Posted by Palo20

According to Madden, LOLB is actually a position in the NFL. I guess it is in most 3-4 schemes.

According to Madden, Lance Briggs and Demarcus Ware play the same position

[Chargersa7x]

Quote: Originally Posted by acarrero

Absurd rating for Big Ben. He should be at least a 94. He is proven to be a better QB than Rogers and obviously Shaub. Rivers is better than Ben? LOL!!! Where's McNabb? He belongs in the 90's too.

Yes.... Rivers is absolutely better than Big Ben.

Guess who had the TOP QB rating the last two years in the AFC. I'll give you a clue... it wasn't Payton Manning, and it certaintly wasn't Big Ben.

Ed Hoc and bad defense cost Rivers an MVP in 2008.

[Chargersa7x]

Quote: Originally Posted by SA1NT401

Why still so generous with the 90++ Ratings Donny? I know i am in the minority here maybe...But a 95+ should be reserved for the top 10 players in the NFL, should be an ELITE rating...Hell, Moss at 95 is WAY too high IMHO....88-89 would be realistic(or a bit less)...and im a PATS fan. The Above average players in the NFL should be mid 80s A good NfL player should be low-mid 70s 60-65 should be the average rating for an NFL player.... Quite a few questionable overalls on that there list... And i think there should only be 3-5 99s in the entire game. Looks like i will have ALOT of player editing to to again this year....

Honestly... can we sticky this? Please?