I thought hitting was nearly perfect last year. but it took some slider work, and a willingness to use the tools 2K provided in a way that made some sense.
I jacked up up the power slider, but used the contact swing 90% of the time. 90% of the times, hitters use a standard swing, and the jacked up power turned the contact swing into a swing that could generate HR's, extra base hits, and singles in surprisingly relaistic fashion.
I did use the power swing if the count went to 2-0 or 3-1. These are counts where the hitter is free to take a chance if he gets the right pitch, because he is taking anything that is not perfect.So this resulted in more power in those hitter's counts, as it should.
I found that this not only resulted in very relaistic results throughout my line-up, but more importantly, it really encouraged me to work the count. So I also generated more walks than I have ever taken in any other baseball game. It cured that tendency to hack away so much.
So they can drop that system right back in, and I will be happy.
I thought the sound was fine. Everybody will complain, becasue the sound of bats are affected by whether you hear them on TV, at the game, and how close you are. So no matter what sound they use, it will always annoy someone.
I didn't care about the arrow, because it was there to put you in position to make a jump if it was close enough. What do you want them to do? Fake a circle in the OF so you don't know? Becasue arrow or not, if there is no circle, you know where it is headed.