MLB 11 The Show Video: St. Louis Cardinals vs. Chicago Cubs (Gameplay)

[Shakedowncapo]

Quote: Originally Posted by countryboy

can we please move the batting stance discussion to this thread: http://www.operationsports.com/forum...batting+stance

We shouldn't have to do that...It can be a healthy conversation. But for the fact that nobody but a few care, I'll handle this through PM.

[ckarlic]

Video looks great!!! Can't Wait!!!!

[travis72]

Quote: Originally Posted by countryboy

that is the WORST!!!! video I have ever seen. There is nothing good about that video, nothing.

LOL, yeah I thought so to should have been the Reds beating the Cards to win the Division,LOL.

[PSUlions15]

Ok, heres my opinion for commentary, they need to put a create-your-own-commetary feature. Here is how it would work. You find voices of commentators, from real life and upload them into the game, for certain situations. Like say it was walk-off in the 9th inning, find the voice of your commentator for that situation, upload it into the game, and add it to that situation.

This is a working idea for me so if sounds a little off that's my fault. So, what you guys think?

[PVarck31]

Alright guys, lets chill out. Consider this a blanket warning.

[slickkill77]

Quote: Originally Posted by PSUlions15

Ok, heres my opinion for commentary, they need to put a create-your-own-commetary feature. Here is how it would work. You find voices of commentators, from real life and upload them into the game, for certain situations. Like say it was walk-off in the 9th inning, find the voice of your commentator for that situation, upload it into the game, and add it to that situation. This is a working idea for me so if sounds a little off that's my fault. So, what you guys think?

It could work in theory. They do it with crowd noises so why not. The only problem is you would end up hearing the same things and you would randomly get announcers popping in out of nowhere that had no involvement in the game. Although I could see people on here recording hours worth of commentary ala the rosters

[PSUlions15]

Quote: Originally Posted by slickkill77

It could work in theory. They do it with crowd noises so why not. The only problem is you would end up hearing the same things and you would randomly get announcers popping in out of nowhere that had no involvement in the game. Although I could see people on here recording hours worth of commentary ala the rosters

No, I mostly meant your speacific teams commentators like for the phillies it would be Gary Matthews, Chris Wheeler and Tom McCarthy, and you could have a bout 3 different voices for that situation so it isnt the same all the time.

[econoodle]

one positive, one negative after watching the clip.

+ lighting! though this setting wasnt even the best use of it. Sunset would look nice.
Hopefully the demo we can pick time of day.
SCEA is masters at getting the most out of the graphical engine with each new installment.
lighting kept this from looking EXACTLY like ten.

Player models are nice but in the flow of this clip, u c ant tell they are new unlesss ur REALLY looking.

- presentation

wow, even with editing of the in between stuff the announcing was B.R.U.T.A.L.

Just brutal.
for 2010.
brutal.
the lack of a decent crowd too killed the feel in that clip.

SCEA, time to overhaul it.
it feels like nappytime watching it. lol

overall, not much to say. The Show visually takes steps forward and then sticks in the mud regarding sound and presentation.
still too much like 10, like 10 was too much like 09.

I really like Matty V in real life, but in this game hes just not good.

presentation is just as important as all the other stuff.

i'll play th demo this week as the controls dont come into play when just watching a clip, so i'll see how that rocks, but from what I have seen so far, I aint feeling this years game two weeks away.