Madden NFL 12 Has Rated Four Players at 99. Overrated? Who Missed the Cut?

[Patriots1996]

Why isn't Manning on this list? If he can make a mediocre offense into one of the best, he deserves a 99. Also, where is Andre Johnson? He is STILL deserving of a 99. Brady is about a 97.


Sent from my iPhone 4 using Tapatalk

[CamNewton4MVP]

Peyton Manning should be a 99 Tom Brady should be a 99 and Aaron Rodgers should be a 97 but yes madden does overate a lot of players

[roadman]

Quote: Originally Posted by Roncatto

They won the Superbowl because they have the best recieving corps in the game right now and they have top defense. Rodgers is very good but look at what brady works with and how good the patriots still are.

Really, did you see the disabled list from last year?

Jermichael Finley, Ryan Grant, Nick Barnett, Morgan Bell, Brandon Chiller, Justin Harrell, Spencer Havner, Brad Jones, Derrick Martin, Mike Neal, Marshall Newhouse, Brady Poppinga, Anthony Smith and Mark Tauscher.

Finley was the #1 receiver going into the year, so, everyone had to make adjustments to Finley and Grant's injury and the above others.

Backups and second/third stringers the rest of the way.

James Starks anyone?

[44drob]

Thas what im talking bout that a boy Antonio 99 deserving rite ???

I was thinking

T.Brady
Aaron Rodgers .... idk ??
Peyton Manning
and....
Chris Johson ..... lol idk

im completely baffled by A.G being 99

[Tyrant8RDFL]

Quote: Originally Posted by SIMstyle

stretched out is right. here's my rating scale. best at position - 94-96 (Brady 95, A.Johnson 96, Manning 96, Fitzgerald 95) pro-bowl players 90-93 (e.g. Ray Lewis, 90) elite (cusp of pro bowl) 87-88 (e.g. Wes Welker, 88) Very Good 85-87 (3 years of consistently good numbers e.g. Anquan Boldin, 87) Good 80-84 (e.g. Hines Ward, 82) average NFL starter 70-79 (Deion Branch, 71) 2nd string bench contributor - 60-69 (Tully Banta-Cain, 66) bench player/special teams standout 50-59 (e.g. Brandon Tate, 52) end of roster/special teams player 40-49 1st rounders - 65-70 2nd rounders - 60-65 3rd rounders - 50-59 drafted after the 4th round - 40-49 rookie free agent - 30-39

I can not have a scale like yours for rookies. Some rookies really shine in their first year , and with your scale that would never happen.

Ratings should be position specific also. I also feel there are way too many ratings in this game for players.

[LiL_MiK3Y]

i've Heard of this one guy his name is Nnamdi Asomugha. Just a less tested than Revis. QBs already know not to pass it near Nnamdi. Jussst Sayinnnnn.

[SteelerSpartan]

I want the ratings stretched out again as well

[Candyman5]

Tom Brady and maybe Revis.
Polyoverated and Gates should not be 99, maybe 90-95. Ed Reed IMO is beter than Poly and I hate the Ravens D but I don't think he should get a 99 as well.

Should be:
Brady-99
Revis- 97-99
Poly- 95
Reed- 97
Gates- 89-90

*Shaked head*

If I see Ray Lewis 90+ I'm really going to lose it.

Sent from me, duh.