Madden NFL 12 Has Rated Four Players at 99. Overrated? Who Missed the Cut?

[BigSpleen]

Quote: Originally Posted by iBlievN5

So, you didn't click the links.

Yes i did again, no CB can tackle a RB with a full head of steam in the open field, and the raiders CB's have to do it more then anyone duw to playing man to man. Learn some football. That link was nothing more then an anti=smear campaign against aso.

Again, manning, woodson others have stated aso is the best. Unless you think Revis could tackle Peterson in the open field< LMAO. Most LB's would have trouble.

CB's are used to support the run, no tackle RB's in the open field, which ios where these stats come from.

[MadLivingLegend]

Lets all be realistic here. At what point in any era did you honestly think a player was the best of the best? In order to have a 99 rating that player needs to be absolutely flawless. Jordan in his prime didn't make every jumpshot, Sweetness didn't gain a consistent 10+ yds a carry, and Agassi didn't win every set! To have a 99 player in any game is FAR FETCHED! These ratings are simply thrown in there because the rating czar says so! Of all the players listed at 99 Tom Brady would be the closest for me. Maybe a 96 at Best!

To give someone a high rating like 99 they have to be without a doubt the best players of their sport, and potentially the greatest of all time. EA Sports is not in the game, They are trying to get in it. Too bad they are failing miserably!

[bkrich83]

Quote: Originally Posted by BigSpleen

Learn some football.

Irony.

10 char.

[bkrich83]

Quote: Originally Posted by MadLivingLegend

Lets all be realistic here. At what point in any era did you honestly think a player was the best of the best? In order to have a 99 rating that player needs to be absolutely flawless. Jordan in his prime didn't make every jumpshot, Sweetness didn't gain a consistent 10+ yds a carry, and Agassi didn't win every set! To have a 99 player in any game is FAR FETCHED! These ratings are simply thrown in there because the rating czar says so! Of all the players listed at 99 Tom Brady would be the closest for me. Maybe a 96 at Best! To give someone a high rating like 99 they have to be without a doubt the best players of their sport, and potentially the greatest of all time. EA Sports is not in the game, They are trying to get in it. Too bad they are failing miserably!

Excellent points.

[Automatik]

Quote: Originally Posted by BigSpleen

Anyone who uses TACKLING RB"S as proof a cb is betteer then another dosnt have a clue that's a fact.

A CB who can tackle is a COMPLETE corner, Deon Sanders was the bes shutdon corner ever but not the most complete corner.
Champ Bailey and Aso are complete corners I've seen both make amzing one on one tackles vs RB,WR etc...
The only reason I haven't put Revis in yet is because he hasn't done it for long enough.

[BigSpleen]

Quote: Originally Posted by bkrich83

Irony. 10 char.

Truth hurts.

[roadman]

Let's see, better open field tackler than Aso that can tackle RB's.

Charles Woodson.

[BigSpleen]

Quote: Originally Posted by Automatik

A CB who can tackle is a COMPLETE corner, Deon Sanders was the bes shutdon corner ever but not the most complete corner. Champ Bailey and Aso are complete corners I've seen both make amzing one on one tackles vs RB,WR etc... The only reason I haven't put Revis in yet is because he hasn't done it for long enough.

Aso is a great tackler, i remember last year he nearly took off Frank gores head. He has taken down RB's in the open with one arm tackles. BUT no Cb can conssitently take down RB in the open field. If you wacth any raider games you know how complete is.