Madden NFL 13 Player Ratings - Top 10 Quarterbacks

[StrawHat Patriot]

Quote: Originally Posted by CRMosier_LM

Stop man really... Sent from my ADR6400L using Tapatalk 2

What's the issue? I'm just giving my take on the conversion. Sorry if that's so bad.

If it's because it's off-topic, then yeah, I will "stop".

[DeuceDouglas]

Quote: Originally Posted by cbenti60

O/U 14.5 days before we all bitch at Donny Moore for putting together awful ratings

Under. More like O/U 14.5 minutes. The edit player complaint threads are going to absolutely explode again come release day.

[balcobomber25]

Eli Manning is a 97??

5 seasons with more than 15 int's
Career QB rating of 82.1
Career completion % of 58
67 fumbles in his career, only 6 less than Vick (who has nearly 600 more rushing attempts)
Only once in his career has he thrown for more than 30 td's
Never won a single season MVP

And EA is telling me this guy is mere points away from three of the best QB's in the league today?? He has played great in the Super Bowl I will give him his credit but so did Mario Manningham should he be a 97 for the WR?? And herein lies the problem with not being able to edit rosters.

[BostonsDaBest]

Based on what happened Matt Cassel between M9 and M10, Matt Flynn should be at an 88 or 89 this year, smh.

[Gaycandybacon]

The Spread is just fine. Every QB will have their Strengths and Weaknesses. Just because they're 90 plus OVR doesn't mean they will always hit their target, or throw 60 yard bombs down the field. Some players can throw on the run better than others.. Some players have better arms than others. Some are more accurate than others in certain aspects of the field (Short, Medium, and Deep). Also, other ratings make the player rated higher. Like speed strength, acceleration, etc. etc. etc. Do you think Tim Tebow is rated the way he is cause he can throw the football? HELL NO! He has all those attrubutes of a HB as well... so his rating is boosted.

Give these ratings a chance. Remember, the Overall rating of a player doesn't tell the whole story.

[Gaycandybacon]

Quote: Originally Posted by BostonsDaBest

Based on what happened Matt Cassel between M9 and M10, Matt Flynn should be at an 88 or 89 this year, smh.

Flynn should be a 79/80. 88 or 89 LOL I don't think they'd go that far...
Wait.... would they..?

[speedy9386]

Quote: Originally Posted by StrawHat Patriot

Dude, it's 2012, and sports games are being critically acclaimed for their realism because video games have advanced enough to look and play pretty realistically. I mean compare M12 to MLB the Show 12 and NBA 2K12 and see how Madden fairs. I'm really not being nitpicky like you think I am. By the way. Madden 94 was released for what, the Super Nintendo or something? Flash forward, and some people find Madden frustrating and boring to play, and many people criticize the game for not being what EA constantly describes it as: "The most Authentic NFL game" "True to the NFL" "What you see on Sundays" The "fun" part of the game is nice and all, and it can still be achieved through realism. Times are changing. I don't want a game that looks like crap and plays like crap, because that wouldn't be fun. We still have arcade style games anyways. Hell, what am I saying, Madden pretty much is EA's own arcade version of the NFL.

This
I think Madden really needs to step it's game up in the area of gameplay and being as authentic as it can possibly be to the nfl.

[Find_the_Door]

LOL Vick and his 18 TD's 14 INT's 59.8 completion percentage and 10 fumbles....

Should be ahead of Romo's 4,184 yards 31 TD's 10 INT's 66.3 completion percentage and 6 fumbles, 4th best passer rating in the league, 3rd best completion percentage in the league (ahead of Brady).

Hell Vick is incredibly fortunate to even be on this list! Romo should be ahead of Rivers and Big Ben!