Madden NFL 13 Ratings - Vote For the Quarterback with the Highest Deep Ball Accuracy

[Find_the_Door]

Quote: Originally Posted by DeuceDouglas

Over the last three years, Eli's been Top 5 in terms of Accuracy Pct. He's also second in both yards and touchdowns. Brees seems to be all around best though. Three Years of Deep Passing

Are these ratings based on this past season or body of work? Because Romo's past season statistically throwing it deep was much better than Eli's and overall they're nearly identical. Romo's past year statistically was better than Eli's as a whole. Does winning a Superbowl make you a more accurate passer? Have a stronger arm?... no.

Romo's deep ball must be higher than Eli's simply because it was better this most recent season, and prior to that it was nearly the same. Romo's deep passing ability took a step up last season, and it's about time that's reflected in the ratings because Romo's current Madden NFL 12 Deep Pass Accuracy rating of 83 is an outright insult.

[DeuceDouglas]

Quote: Originally Posted by Batum Shaka Laka

Are these ratings based on this past season or body of work? Because Romo's past season statistically throwing it deep was much better than Eli's and overall they're nearly identical. Romo's past year statistically was better than Eli's as a whole. Does winning a Superbowl make you a more accurate passer? Have a stronger arm?... no. Romo's deep ball must be higher than Eli's simply because it was better this most recent season, and prior to that it was nearly the same. Romo's deep passing ability took a step up last season, and it's about time that's reflected in the ratings because Romo's current Madden NFL 12 Deep Pass Accuracy rating of 83 is an outright insult.

I'd say they're based on a bit of both in terms of last year and body of work. If they were based on last year's alone, Philip Rivers wouldn't be a 92 overall or whatever he is. Basing ratings solely on the most recent season is where a large portion of the ratings get jacked up.

[Find_the_Door]

Quote: Originally Posted by DeuceDouglas

I'd say they're based on a bit of both in terms of last year and body of work. If they were based on last year's alone, Philip Rivers wouldn't be a 92 overall or whatever he is. Basing ratings solely on the most recent season is where a large portion of the ratings get jacked up.

Yeah I understand that, I mean, body of work has to play some role. What I'm saying is Romo and Eli were nearly identical up until last year, that should be reflected with Romo having a higher deep ball than Eli in Madden 13.

[1D4ever]

Eli is on the list because the NYG won the super bowl and they wanted to to stick him on one of the list he should not be in the top 3 based on any stat. The same reason Vick was not on THP list because the used him for the QB speed list not because he lost arm strength.

[JerzeyReign]

Quote: Originally Posted by DUDERMAN

Where's the "none of the above" option?

Yeah, I'm not even getting past the third post in this one lol. Where is Mike Vick? He throws one of, if not the best, deep balls in the league! He's not getting any love as a passer, huh? EA just wants to keep him as a scrambler forever, lol.

/homerism (but seriously, show Mike some love!)

[Find_the_Door]

Quote: Originally Posted by JerzeyReign

Yeah, I'm not even getting past the third post in this one lol. Where is Mike Vick? He throws one of, if not the best, deep balls in the league! He's not getting any love as a passer, huh? EA just wants to keep him as a scrambler forever, lol. /homerism (but seriously, show Mike some love!)

Go back a page in the thread please

[MaddenSaints]

So basically Brees should be on here but he is not...wow

[420 others]

AceBoog1e, Killa, Killa Cam, Cam, Cammy Cam Cam, Hightop Cleatus, Cam Newton.