Best Madden for Penalties and Injuries From M16 Onward?

[willboat75]

Title says it all. I'm to the point where the gameplay in Madden is fine for whatever game in this new generation that you pick up. However, I want some variation and penalties. Which Madden game gives the most realistic numbers for those two things?

[malky]

I personally liked 18. Injuries galore you really have to hit on prospects in order to win consecutively

[gr18]

Madden 18 was the the first to have off ball injuries and at a good rate.Its an underrated game because the final patch made it good around the time the season ended finally but 16 was the only modern game that got penalties right.You actually had defensive holding called regularly and fatigue actually worked.

So as far as what your asking,I think that those things have only gotten progressively worse.