if you had to choose one game.. which would it be

[bosox!]

lets pretend that all these games didnt have online play, (only offline play, which game In your opinion is the best baseball game (gold, silver, bronze)
(if one of your choices is not here, feel free to list it anyways!- and explain why you chose it!

[davefeelsright]

of course everyone will pick mvp

[mattstl77]

MVP 2005 by far. Franchise was awesome on that game. It revolutionized baseball games from that point on. It is not a coincidence that all games since then have been trying to achieve its greatness.

It is sad that EA is not able to capitalize on their success.

[Heelfan71]

yeah, MVP was a classic. MVP is now #2 on my all time list behind (can't say because this is not the right forum but it's another BB game that just came out).

[mgoblue678]

Any particular reason The Show 09 isn't listed? It easily gets my vote for being not just the best baseball sim of all time but the best sports sim of all time.

MVP is definatly my number 2, it was fun but from a sim/realistic standpoint it is a distant 2nd behind The Show.

[deucepoppi17]

Baseball Stars....but that might be a little too old for some of u on here!

[Helios12787]

Well I hold a special place in my heart for Ken Griffey Jr. Baseball. (left, left, right, right, right, left, left anyone ??? lol)

MVP 05 is still a top baseball game in its state now.

With 2k9 coming out tomorrow I wanna say that will be on the top of my list but with the lack of editing features (which were in previous games) I'd say its gonna take a close second.

[JoshCA916]

Quote: Originally Posted by deucepoppi17

Baseball Stars....but that might be a little too old for some of u on here!

agreed building a team on that game was great, followed by Little League Championship Series on the NES