2008 Cliff Lee=1993 John Burkett

[mAiLmAn 502]

if he was top 10 in the ratings i wouldve laughed and laughed. i cant believe u guys are so pro-cliff lee. he will go 12-12 with an era of 4.3

[redsox0717]

if you're going to make an obvious troll topic, at least compare him to someone who makes sense, 1993 john burkett? his era was lower the next year. you should of said something like 2003 esteban loaiza.

[mAiLmAn 502]

let me guess 70% of you on here are show fanboys and dont know baseball or john burkett? jack mcdowell? billy swift, fernando valenzuela, pat hentgen, etc. enter cliff lee here

[mAiLmAn 502]

im stating lee will never dominate and fade away in 3 yrs, like the rest, mcdowell won 20 then 22, then what? do u think lee will dominate? this isnt trolling this is a debate. lol see i didnt even remmember loazia, great point, does he still have a job?

[Tweeg]

Quote: Originally Posted by mAiLmAn 502

im stating lee will never dominate and fade away in 3 yrs, like the rest, mcdowell won 20 then 22, then what? do u think lee will dominate? this isnt trolling this is a debate. lol see i didnt even remmember loazia, great point, does he still have a job?

The ratings aren't supposed to be a judge of how the player will produce in 3 years. They are supposed to be an accurate depiction of where the player ranks in today's game. If you don't think Cliff Lee is a top 10 pitcher right now than you are sadly mistaken. Debate over.

[mAiLmAn 502]

by the all star break he will be edited way down, im not talking about the ratings really i guess, im just seeing guys call him unhittable and everyone on the carl pavano i mean cliff lee banwagon. if he makes it thru the yr without injury kudos to him

[soxnut1018]

As a White Sox fan, I saw way too much of Cliff Lee. I say the rating is deserved.

[JoeCoolMan24]

Quote: Originally Posted by mAiLmAn 502

im stating lee will never dominate and fade away in 3 yrs, like the rest, mcdowell won 20 then 22, then what? do u think lee will dominate? this isnt trolling this is a debate. lol see i didnt even remmember loazia, great point, does he still have a job?

Y3aH! U R LieK toTa11y R1gHT! L33 Shud B LieK R3alLy Bad N StuFf in Da Gayme bECuz I ThiNk he Will B bAD nexT Seasun.


No.... You fail.