Re-Ranking NCAA 14

[catcher_0_3]

Let me first start off by thanking all of the guys who are naming the rosters, fixing heights/weights/positions/numbers, etc. that will allow us a more realistic experiences playing as our favorite teams. I understand their desire to not adjust the ratings of the players for the headache that it causes for them because you will never please everyone. However, I've loaded up on extra strength Tylenol and would like to ask the community to weigh in on the teams that they truly know so that we can adjust some of the inaccurate player ratings that the game comes with. Let us all try and stay reasonable and level headed please. Try and resist nit picking others' rosters so that we can't get as many of these things done. Now, we need some criteria to follow. I understand that this won't be perfect, but I do think that these will at least give us all a standard to follow.

Template:

Name-Number-Recommended Overall Rating: Notes if necessary

Overall Rating:

Spoiler

99-95: One of the best players at their position of the past 5-10 years. Should dominate

94-90: One of the best players on their team and in their conference. Should be on preseason lists and looking at being drafted in the early rounds of next year's draft.

89-85: Very good players who could be the best player on their team depending on level of play. Will likely end up on the 1st or 2nd team on their All-Conference squad. They are looking at being drafted in the middle rounds if they were to come out.

84-80: Starters at most levels of college football. If they were to enter the NFL they would be looking at late round draft grades or UDFA status

79-75: Starters at the mid major level of a lot of college teams. Could potentially be starters for an odd BCS team position

74-70: Walk ons, depth players, or average to lower level collegiate players

69-65: Shouldn't be starters unless they are at a thin position on a poor college team

60-55: Depth players at the lowest levels of lowest levels of the mid majors

55-50: Walk ons for poor teams

50-0: Probably should be playing at the FCS level or lower

Freshman Ranking Guide:

Spoiler

84-80: Top 50-100 players in the country

79-75: Top 300 players

74-70: Solid 3*, but bottom of most high end BCS classes

69-65: Middle of the pack 3* players. Could fill out some middle BCS teams or good mid majors

64-60: Lower 3* players, will likely fill out mostly mid major classes

59-55: 2 Star players, definitely lower mid major recruits or walk ons at the BCS level

54-50: Lower 2 star players or unranked

Edited Rosters:

SEC
Georgia
Alabama

Pac 12
Oregon State

[pmurray20]

I'm willing to help. What's the best website to check 40times for every team. Instead of having to search by player.

[Wilson16NCSU]

1. Dylan
2. Dylan
3. Dylan
4. Dylan
5. Dylan

[cparrish]

IMO, going off a chart for 40 times does not work unless you give everyone the same acceleration rating. Acceleration is a variable, and if you change that variable from player to player, it changes the outcome of their desired "40 time speed" no matter what their speed rating is.

An example would be you have Player A and Player B who both run 4.40 in the dash. Now giving them both 91 speed works if they both have the same acceleration, but if Player A has 91 speed and 94 acceleration, he will be faster than Player B with 91 speed and 83 acceleration.

[pmurray20]

Quote: Originally Posted by cparrish

IMO, going off a chart for 40 times does not work unless you give everyone the same acceleration rating. Acceleration is a variable, and if you change that variable from player to player, it changes the outcome of their desired "40 time speed" no matter what their speed rating is. An example would be you have Player A and Player B who both run 4.40 in the dash. Now giving them both 91 speed works if they both have the same acceleration, but if Player A has 91 speed and 94 acceleration, he will be faster than Player B with 91 speed and 83 acceleration.

How about agility ?

[catcher_0_3]

I just put the 40 times for a reference if people knew what their team's players ran. I didn't necessarily put it there for everyone to tweak their players, but since speed is such a major part of the game, I thought it could be something that people could look to. Alright, to start it off, here is my University of Georgia.

11 Aaron Murray- 94- Throw Power: 90, Throw Acc: 92
14 Hutson Mason- 83
2 Parker Welch- 79
12 Brice Ramsey- 76
16 Christian LeMay- 75
10 Faton Bauta- 72


HB-
3 Todd Gurley- 92
4 Keith Marshall- 87
20 Brandon Harton (Walk on)- 79
24 AJ Turman- 75
15 J.J. Green- 75 (Scat Back/Elusive)

FB-
43 Merritt Hall- 85 (75ish injury rating)
48 Quayvon Hicks- 79

WR-
26 Malcolm Mitchell- 88
31 Chris Conley- 86
82 Michael Bennett- 85
18 Johnathan Rumph- 84
17 Rantavious Wooten- 80
86 Justin Scott Welsey- 79
1 Trammel Terry- 79
8 Blake Tibbs- 6’2” 175 Black- (RS) Freshman- Georgia- 78 (if not on the roster replace McGowan with him)
27 Rhett McGowan- 78- walk on
81 Uriah LeMay- 75
Reggie Davis- 69
Rico Johnson- 68

TE- There might be a Sophomore TE on the roster, if so replace him with Davis
87 Jay Rome- 86
88 Arthurn Lynch- 84
(unknown #) Jordan Davis- 6’4” 235 Black- Freshman- Georgia- 73

LT-
72 Kenarious Gates- 87
79 Mark Beard- 82
76 Zach DeBell- 79

LG-
64 Dallas Lee- 84
78 Watts Dantzler- 80
60 Josh Cardiello- 74

C-
61 David Andrews- 85
67 on TB roster Brandon Kublanow- 80
66 Hunter Long- 77


RG-
68 Chris Burnette- 82
74 Austin Long- 78
73 Greg Pyke- 6’6” 327 White- (RS) Freshman- Maryland- 77 (Replace Long with Pyke if not on roster)

RT-
71 John Theus- 84
63 Xavier Ward- 6’7” 293 Black- (RS) Sophomore- Georgia- 79 (If not on roster, replace LT #75)
70 Aulden Bynum- 6’5” 260 White- Freshman- Georgia- 69


LE-
99 Toby Johnson- 6’5” 310 Black- Junior- Georgia- 84
94 John Taylor- 82

RE-
56 Garrison Smith- 87
58 Sterling Bailey- 84
47 Ray Drew- 82

DT-
91 Mike Thorton- 83
93 Chris Mayes- 81
97 John Atkins- 79
95 DeAndre Johnson- 72

LOLB-
89 James DeLoach- 82
53 Leonard Floyd- 82
33 Chase Vasser- 6’3” 231 White- (RS) Senior- Georgia (he was given an extremely high rating, I doubt he will be on the 2 deep at either OLB position)- 78
Shaun McGee- 6’3” 230 Black- Freshman- Georgia- 75

MLB-
52 Amarlo Herrera- 87
51 Ramik Wilson- 83
45 Reggie Carter- 77
50 Johnny O'Neal- 76
38 Ryne Rankin- 75
42 Tim Kimbrough- 5’11” 230 Black- Freshman- Indiana- 72

ROLB-
59 Jordan Jenkins- 88
91 Josh Dawson- 80
17 Davin Bellamy- 6’5” 235 Black- Freshman- Georgia- 79
44 TJ Stripling- 77


CB-
5 Damiann Swann- 87
2 Sheldon Dawson- 81
Kennar Johnson- 6’2” 185 Black w/dreads- Junior- Florida- 80 (Would replace Sailors for him)
27 Brendan Langely- 6’1” 180 Medium- Freshman- Georgia- 78
9 Reggie Wilkerson- 77 (Out for season with injury)
37 Devin Bowman- 76
21 Shaq Wiggins- 76
7 Blake Sailors- 72

FS-
24 Shaq Fluker- 83
39 Corey Moore- 79
11 Connor Norman- 72
20 Quincy Mauger- 70

SS-
25 Josh-Harvey Clemons- 82
28 Tray Matthews- 78
Paris Bostick- 75
23 Marc Deas- 74

K-
13 Marshall Morgan- 79

P-
32 Colin Barber- 77

[pmurray20]

I'm looking forward to see what everyone has to say about there teams

[cparrish]

Quote: Originally Posted by pmurray20

How about agility ?

It has nothing to do with straight line speed. Agility just effects the players ability to change direction without slowing down. Someone like Braxton Miller would have his agility rating maxed out, while Taylor Martinez would have a low agility rating because he is all about straight line speed and cannot cut very well.