Just purchased an XBOX and NCAA 06, 07

[sunless]

[pujolsformvp21]

06 was my fav ncaa of all time had so much fun with mizzou and brad smith. had so much fun with this game that i could overlook the gamebreaking direct snap cheese where it is literally 5-10 yards a play without fail by using it out of shotgun. also the fact that the deep ball was basically money with any qb or wr. thats the thing i think ppl forget is that our expectations were lower and the technology was much more impressive back then as we expect way too much now and nit pick every aspect rather than just play like we used to. 06 like i said was my favorite but like every other ncaa there are gamebreaking glitches, we just seem to be more understanding back then. if it were the EXACT same game ported over to 360 today, like literally the exact same (not possible i know) but it would be ripped to shreds on these forums. /rant over

[R.Moncrief]

Quote: Originally Posted by pujolsformvp21

like i said was my favorite but like every other ncaa there are gamebreaking glitches, we just seem to be more understanding back then. if it were the EXACT same game ported over to 360 today, like literally the exact same (not possible i know) but it would be ripped to shreds on these forums. /rant over

I usually stay out of the threads that praise old gen NCAAF games because of what you just said. Honestly, those games weren't so great. Just watch some footage on youtube and you want to puke at the thought of it. Not just from a graphic standpoint either. Gameplay wise, NCAA 14 blows it out of the water. The only impressive thing IMO was the FCS schools but really, is that a game changer? I don't know.

Let me get going before I'm forum-assassinated..

[The JareBear]

Quote: Originally Posted by R.Moncrief

I usually stay out of the threads that praise old gen NCAAF games because of what you just said. Honestly, those games weren't so great. Just watch some footage on youtube and you want to puke at the thought of it. Not just from a graphic standpoint either. Gameplay wise, NCAA 14 blows it out of the water. The only impressive thing IMO was the FCS schools but really, is that a game changer? I don't know. Let me get going before I'm forum-assassinated..

I think reality is somewhere in the middle.

Take your guys' view, take the view that those games were perfect, and just place the dial smack dab in the middle and it's probably close to the truth.

I am sure we all, or at least the majority, had a LOT of fun with those games. That being said, yes, the deep ball was cheese, there were some insanely cheesy money plays, I just think back then, in the era before the "Online Pro Gamer" we really didn't look at it like the way we look at it now. I would play my buddy on the same screen and we would both drop back 30 yards and rocket the ball all over the field. We were young, we didn't care about sliders or "sim ball." When I do look at vids from those games, it is pretty clear how easy it is to move the ball and get away with some pretty cheesetastic strategies.

That being said, they were feature rich and stacked with gameplay options.

[Peacefrog]

Quote: Originally Posted by The JareBear

That being said, they were feature rich and stacked with gameplay options.

The biggest difference between then and now is that back then, these worked! From day one, straight out of the box, the features all worked. I don't think there's been a game this gen that can boast that all of its features worked 100% as advertised, even after patching.

[simgamer0005]

Quote: Originally Posted by Peacefrog

The biggest difference between then and now is that back then, these worked! From day one, straight out of the box, the features all worked. I don't think there's been a game this gen that can boast that all of its features worked 100% as advertised, even after patching.

Yup, it worked on last-gen because everyone had the same game. You didn't have to worry that your friend had a patched version of the game. all you needed was the disc and a memory card and you could go over your friends house and have it at and knew you'd get solid gameplay 100% of the time.

as for 06 and the direct snap out of shotgun cheese mentioned, this was only really an issue vs the CPU. All you had to do is manually control a player and put him next to the D-end and the RB won't get 5-10 yards every time.

But against the CPU in the standard formations, it was very effective. A safety blitz or an OLB blitz play could stop it, but the CPU didn't recognize it and call those plays enough. especially on 3rd downs, even 3rd and long, and the D was in pass coverage, you could run those shotgun direct snaps and get first downs , especially with a quick RB. And on 3rd or 4th and short, it was pretty much an auto first down. and that was one of the problems with the game. (vs the CPU, not really problem vs a human play-caller)

I'm wondering if there's a way to improve this exploit vs the CPU with sliders in 06. one of the reasons why I like NCAA 03 is because issues like this don't exist and it's really a very balanced game vs the CPU. NCAA 2005 the defense was much better at defending the deep ball, in fact it probably had the best pass defending of any NCAA last-gen game, but the running game and closedown lanes had its share of problems in 2005.

[sunless]

Quote: Originally Posted by R.Moncrief

Just watch some footage on youtube and you want to puke at the thought of it.

Actually I was watching some old videos on youtube and that's what spurred me to make the purchases. All that matters to me is what a game looks like in motion. The last gen games looked beautiful in motion because of the smooth running animations. That is my biggest gripe with current gen. Looks great in stills but horrible in motion as the players run around like the tin man.

[simgamer0005]

Quote: Originally Posted by sunless

Actually I was watching some old videos on youtube and that's what spurred me to make the purchases. All that matters to me is what a game looks like in motion. The last gen games looked beautiful in motion because of the smooth running animations. That is my biggest gripe with current gen. Looks great in stills but horrible in motion as the players run around like the tin man.

I agree completely, but I don't even think current gen looks great in stills. The stadiums look bigger and more realistic, the crowd in the stadium more detailed. That's about it. The player models clearly looked better in stills and in motion on last gen. Last gen suspends your disbelief, it's cheesy at times, but it suspends your disbelief. In no way does current gen suspend your disbelief.

The physics, the player controls, even the features were better and more user friendly on last gen. Also the game was much smoother since it was pound for pound a more efficient engine. Last gen had all the details too, like the chain gain, even detailed sidelines from NCAA 2005-2008 on last gen. You could overlook the quirks because the game was so fun and satisfying to play.