More Links

clemsoncarl · 11-06-2013, 05:52 PM

Inspired by EA Sports' article entitled 101 Reasons to Buy NCAA Football 14, I present my own 10 Reasons to Buy NCAA Football 13 (Over NCAA Football 14)!

Original EA Sports article here

Background
I keep going back and forth between NCAA 13 and 14, and there are lots of good features about NCAA 13 that people are overlooking, and I have enumerated them here. This is not an attempt to incite a flame war, instead, if we are going to be stuck with only these games for the near future, we need to better understand their strong and weak points.

I actually own both games, and I recommend that others do the same since these are the last in this great series -- NCAA 13 gamers should have NCAA 14, and NCAA 14 gamers should have NCAA 13.

Obvious Weak Points of NCAA 13
*"4 Verticals" money play (but this can be banned with a "gentleman's rule" and in offline play)
*Too many INTs (but this can be easily fixed with sliders)

10 REASONS TO BUY NCAA FOOTBALL 13 (OVER NCAA FOOTBALL 14)
Team-specific entrances (such as Clemson's running down the hill!! - Not found in NCAA 14)

Realistic injury rate (injuries are exceptionally rare in NCAA Football 14)

Realistic fumble rate (rare in NCAA Football 14 and can't be easily fixed with sliders because there's no "Fumble" slider)

Fully patched (Many were expecting further patches from EA Sports when NCAA 14 was abruptly canceled)

Cheaper (Currently $18 vs. $48 for NCAA 14 on Amazon.)

More in-depth recruiting -- You control the specific pitches made to each recruit. This enables you to "get to know" each recruit better and become more immersed in the recruiting process. NCAA 14's recruiting is more statistical and less engaging.

Sleek and intuitive in-game menus, not the Windows 8-inspired tile menus

No long Nissan in-game commercial

No RPG "leveling up" -- You level up the old fashioned way, You earn it by getting better! This is a skill-based game, remember? Don't need to worry about accumulating XP by running up the score either.

Erin Andrews! (Although admittedly, only the audio.)

The JareBear · 11-06-2013, 06:04 PM

I agree that coach XP isn't that realistic (IMO) and about the injury/fumbles.

Disagree about everything else. I don't have any issues with the menus, and I can't stand the old recruiting system, made no sense to me.

I also think that NCAA 13 plays a decent game of football, but with sliders and maybe minimal house rules regarding the spread option, NCAA 14 plays fantastic. Since the patch, CPU coverage has been so much better, I haven't seen the DB glitch once.

jeremym480 · 11-06-2013, 06:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by clemsoncarl


	10 REASONS TO BUY NCAA FOOTBALL 13 (OVER NCAA FOOTBALL 14) Team-specific entrances (such as Clemson's running down the hill!! - Not found in NCAA 14) I do miss the entrances Realistic injury rate (injuries are exceptionally rare in NCAA Football 14) I don't think I've had an injury through 4-5 seasons in 14. but injuries were few and far between for me in 13, as well. Very frustrating Realistic fumble rate (rare in NCAA Football 14 and can't be easily fixed with sliders because there's no "Fumble" slider) Also very frustrating. This, the injuries and soft coverage's are my three biggest complaints about 14 Fully patched (Many were expecting further patches from EA Sports when NCAA 14 was abruptly canceled) Even though it's full patched 14 simply plays better. Plus, the DB Glitch isn't as prevalent in 14. I've actually only seen in two times and that was within the first week of release. *knocks on wood Cheaper (Currently $18 vs. $48 for NCAA 14 on Amazon.) That's certainly a positive for someone who doesn't own either game. the question would be is there enough difference's and pro's in 14 to justify the $30 difference. Ehh, game play wise it's a toss up, however the one area where 14 excels over 13 is the CPU's ability to actually win games. See my sig below. Most of those L's have came to CPU teams. That's never happened to me before in NCAA. More in-depth recruiting -- You control the specific pitches made to each recruit. This enables you to "get to know" each recruit better and become more immersed in the recruiting process. NCAA 14's recruiting is more statistical and less engaging. 14 may be less engaging, but is actually deeper when you consider things like competitive visits, getting locked out, etc. Sleek and intuitive in-game menus, not the Windows 8-inspired tile menus Menu's are much quicker in 14 No long Nissan in-game commercial this isn't something that bothers me, but the cut ins by Rece Davis are placed much better in 14 No RPG "leveling up" -- You level up the old fashioned way, You earn it by getting better! This is a skill-based game, remember? Don't need to worry about accumulating XP by running up the score either. I'm not a big fan of the RPG element either, honestly. Erin Andrews! (Although admittedly, only the audio.) I'm much more of a visual person.

Responses in red.

buckeyebaggins4 · 11-06-2013, 07:29 PM

you missed the biggest one; STADIUM SOUNDS ACTUALLY WORK

malky · 11-06-2013, 07:58 PM

While I actually might agree with you, there is one small little tiny tiny little issue that makes 13 a disaster:

IT FREEZES ALL THE TIME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! and this is after the patch, so I actually wouldn't know how good 13 is because of the constant freezing, and don't care to go back and be frustrated again, so I'll stick with 14.

Clemsonpanther · 11-06-2013, 09:20 PM

Play NCAA 12.

clemsoncarl · 11-07-2013, 01:57 AM

Thanks for the feedback, especially the in-depth responses from jeremym480.
I keep wavering between NCAA 13 and 14 because each has its own good and bad points. I am tempted to give 14 another look after your feedback.

I admit that injuries are still too few in NCAA 13. Another thing is that they (almost) always seem to happen to the ball carrier or someone who was involved with the ball. No injuries seem to happen away from the ball (ie. OL or DL).

One thing about switching between NCAA 13 and 14 is that the controls are slightly different, particularly for running the option.

Clemsonpanther, you mentioned, NCAA 12. It's been over a year since I played that, and I've forgotten what it's good and bad points were....

Clemsonpanther · 11-07-2013, 07:47 AM

bad of 12

Ahtletes are useless
There are psychic DBs (but they can be made rare with sliders)
I dont play with injuries so I don't know about that
The option almost impossible to run
The graphics arent as pretty as 14, but are good enough to play with
Custom playbooks have a few unremovable plays

Positives
Defense is stellar
You get to play with past players
Passing is a CHALLENGE
Real life team entrances
Good and bad teams are more varied to play against
Games are more varied (not always shootouts)
Defensive coverage is useful
Recruiting is harder
More playbook plays
I could go on and on.

11-06-2013, 05:52 PM	#1
clemsoncarl Rookie OVR: 0 Join Date: Dec 2011	10 Reasons to Buy NCAA Football 13 (Over NCAA Football 14) Inspired by EA Sports' article entitled 101 Reasons to Buy NCAA Football 14, I present my own 10 Reasons to Buy NCAA Football 13 (Over NCAA Football 14)! Original EA Sports article here Background I keep going back and forth between NCAA 13 and 14, and there are lots of good features about NCAA 13 that people are overlooking, and I have enumerated them here. This is not an attempt to incite a flame war, instead, if we are going to be stuck with only these games for the near future, we need to better understand their strong and weak points. I actually own both games, and I recommend that others do the same since these are the last in this great series -- NCAA 13 gamers should have NCAA 14, and NCAA 14 gamers should have NCAA 13. Obvious Weak Points of NCAA 13 "4 Verticals" money play (but this can be banned with a "gentleman's rule" and in offline play) Too many INTs (but this can be easily fixed with sliders) 10 REASONS TO BUY NCAA FOOTBALL 13 (OVER NCAA FOOTBALL 14) Team-specific entrances (such as Clemson's running down the hill!! - Not found in NCAA 14) Realistic injury rate (injuries are exceptionally rare in NCAA Football 14) Realistic fumble rate (rare in NCAA Football 14 and can't be easily fixed with sliders because there's no "Fumble" slider) Fully patched (Many were expecting further patches from EA Sports when NCAA 14 was abruptly canceled) Cheaper (Currently $18 vs. $48 for NCAA 14 on Amazon.) More in-depth recruiting -- You control the specific pitches made to each recruit. This enables you to "get to know" each recruit better and become more immersed in the recruiting process. NCAA 14's recruiting is more statistical and less engaging. Sleek and intuitive in-game menus, not the Windows 8-inspired tile menus No long Nissan in-game commercial No RPG "leveling up" -- You level up the old fashioned way, You earn it by getting better! This is a skill-based game, remember? Don't need to worry about accumulating XP by running up the score either. Erin Andrews! (Although admittedly, only the audio.) crpuga and Clemsonpanther like this.

11-06-2013, 06:04 PM	#2
The JareBear Be Good To One Another OVR: 49 Join Date: Jul 2010 Location: Colorado Posts: 11,574 Blog Entries: 17	Re: 10 Reasons to Buy NCAA Football 13 (Over NCAA Football 14) I agree that coach XP isn't that realistic (IMO) and about the injury/fumbles. Disagree about everything else. I don't have any issues with the menus, and I can't stand the old recruiting system, made no sense to me. I also think that NCAA 13 plays a decent game of football, but with sliders and maybe minimal house rules regarding the spread option, NCAA 14 plays fantastic. Since the patch, CPU coverage has been so much better, I haven't seen the DB glitch once. __________________ "Successful people do not celebrate in the adversity or misfortune of others." OS Blog The Tortured Mind Of A Rockies Fan. In Arenado I Trust.

11-06-2013, 07:29 PM	#4
buckeyebaggins4 Rookie OVR: 0 Join Date: Apr 2012	Re: 10 Reasons to Buy NCAA Football 13 (Over NCAA Football 14) you missed the biggest one; STADIUM SOUNDS ACTUALLY WORK Cardot likes this.

11-06-2013, 07:58 PM	#5
malky MVP OVR: 11 Join Date: Feb 2009	Re: 10 Reasons to Buy NCAA Football 13 (Over NCAA Football 14) While I actually might agree with you, there is one small little tiny tiny little issue that makes 13 a disaster: IT FREEZES ALL THE TIME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! and this is after the patch, so I actually wouldn't know how good 13 is because of the constant freezing, and don't care to go back and be frustrated again, so I'll stick with 14. illiterateoption likes this. __________________ Games I'm playing FOREVER: NFL2K5, That is all.

11-06-2013, 09:20 PM	#6
Clemsonpanther MVP OVR: 3 Join Date: Apr 2012 Location: USA Posts: 1,031 Blog Entries: 3	Re: 10 Reasons to Buy NCAA Football 13 (Over NCAA Football 14) Play NCAA 12. Tuscaloosa likes this.

	New OS Forums Are Coming on May 1
	The Best Sports Gaming Year of All-Time
	Arcade Sports Games Need a Revival

11-07-2013, 01:57 AM	#7
clemsoncarl Rookie OVR: 0 Join Date: Dec 2011	Re: 10 Reasons to Buy NCAA Football 13 (Over NCAA Football 14) Thanks for the feedback, especially the in-depth responses from jeremym480. I keep wavering between NCAA 13 and 14 because each has its own good and bad points. I am tempted to give 14 another look after your feedback. I admit that injuries are still too few in NCAA 13. Another thing is that they (almost) always seem to happen to the ball carrier or someone who was involved with the ball. No injuries seem to happen away from the ball (ie. OL or DL). One thing about switching between NCAA 13 and 14 is that the controls are slightly different, particularly for running the option. Clemsonpanther, you mentioned, NCAA 12. It's been over a year since I played that, and I've forgotten what it's good and bad points were....

11-07-2013, 07:47 AM	#8
Clemsonpanther MVP OVR: 3 Join Date: Apr 2012 Location: USA Posts: 1,031 Blog Entries: 3	Re: 10 Reasons to Buy NCAA Football 13 (Over NCAA Football 14) bad of 12 Ahtletes are useless There are psychic DBs (but they can be made rare with sliders) I dont play with injuries so I don't know about that The option almost impossible to run The graphics arent as pretty as 14, but are good enough to play with Custom playbooks have a few unremovable plays Positives Defense is stellar You get to play with past players Passing is a CHALLENGE Real life team entrances Good and bad teams are more varied to play against Games are more varied (not always shootouts) Defensive coverage is useful Recruiting is harder More playbook plays I could go on and on.