OS Community Roster Rerating Project 2015-2016 (all 30 teams, sign up here!)

[ilvpoon]

PS4 will be the base!! But Xbox users don't hesitate to give your input, we need your knowledge!!

So I think Beds and the 2k staff do a decent enough job with the ratings, but they have too many masters to fill to be completely ruthless and to rate player's weaknesses accurately. Most notably, defense, speed/quickness/acceleration, and tendencies.
The lengths/wingspans and badges will all be edited as well.

Every time I have done this on my own in past 2k games it's worked out to a MUCH more fun and realistic game and you can tell the difference between NBA players. This is a LONG process to do 30 teams.

These edits will be using the full scope of 25-99.
Example:
Chris Kaman speed = 27
James Harden on ball d and help defense CONSIDERABLY lowered to the low 30s, etc.
Kevin Martin strength = 26

I have no hardline "rules" yet for these rosters, but as I search for more info on %age - rating conversion rates, I'll let you know.
Example:
45% 3s = 99 3pt rating


For right now, most of these edits are going to subjective to the editors opinion, but I would like them to be somewhat uniform across the league to make the players accurate to scale
Example:
John Wall should be rated very high in speed and quickness, slightly higher than Mike Conley, but much higher than Jeff Green, who would be much higher than Paul Pierce.

Ideally, these ratings would be discussed here, especially any time there is any discrepancy between opinions in the community.

************************************************** ************
I'm looking for hardcore watchers of NBA basketball to help me completely re rate every player in the game. I want to do it team by team, accurately reflecting real life advanced stats. I think one OS member per team would do the trick.

Please respond with what team you would like to re rate in the thread and maybe we can set up a whatsapp group or discuss here


Atlanta Hawks
Boston Celtics
Charlotte Bobcats
Chicago Bulls
Cleveland Cavaliers
Dallas Mavericks
Denver Nuggets
Detroit Pistons
Golden State Warriors
Houston Rockets
Indiana Pacers
LA Clippers
LA Lakers
Memphis Grizzlies
Miami Heat
Milwaukee Bucks
Minnesota Timberwolves
New Jersey Nets
New Orleans Hornets
New York Knicks
Oklahoma City Thunder
Orlando Magic
Philadelphia Sixers
Phoenix Suns
Portland Trail Blazers - iLvpoon
Sacramento Kings
San Antonio Spurs
Toronto Raptors
Utah Jazz
Washington Wizards

[Jaiveer]

I can try raptors, but might end up overrating some

[ilvpoon]

Quote: Originally Posted by Jaiveer

I can try raptors, but might end up overrating some

I would like these rosters to be as accurate as possible, so if you can't look at the whole league as a spectrum when rating them I'd rather not rate them at all.

[SonicMage]

Eventually I'll have lots of tendencies for you from this season here: Sonicmage Sportscrunch Rosters

People like to rag on Harden's D but he's actually not bad this year. One of the top in the league at P&R defense and near the top for 1-on-1 D.

NBA.com Iso defense

NBA.com P&R defense

[Barncore]

Quote: Originally Posted by Sonicmage

Eventually I'll have lots of tendencies for you from this season here: Sonicmage Sportscrunch Rosters People like to rag on Harden's D but he's actually not bad this year. One of the top in the league at P&R defense and near the top for 1-on-1 D. NBA.com Iso defense NBA.com P&R defense

Don't put too much stock into those stats. Teammates can affect your rank in things like that. Dwight often saves Haren's butt.

That said, Haren's on-ball D is decent. When he has 1 player to focus on he can give a guy trouble, because he's got a big body and good reaction speed when he's locked in. It's his off-ball defense where he's awful. But it's not even an ability thing, it's often just a losing focus thing. Doesn't seem to care whether they score or not sometimes. I don't know. But in conclusion: it's his consistency and help defense that's bad, not his on-ball D. But let's not go overboard and say that his on-ball D is good, per se, it's just not below average. Somewhere between average and decent.

[Jaiveer]

Quote: Originally Posted by ilvpoon

I would like these rosters to be as accurate as possible, so if you can't look at the whole league as a spectrum when rating them I'd rather not rate them at all.

okay I can try like warriors because klay has a posterizer badge so that it is going to go out

[BUCKSWEATSHIRT]

Quote: Originally Posted by Jaiveer

okay I can try like warriors because klay has a posterizer badge so that it is going to go out

Klay actually has dunked on a good amount of people in his time in the league. And also I can do the Bulls


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Jaiveer]

Yeah but there are some people who don't have it and they are way better Dunkers